@dansup @pixelfed Personally I prefer the 2nd one, looks a bit more appy and open as opposed to corporate and big data miner (which the first kinda looks like).
Just my opinion though so don't go based on my words XD

@dansup @pixelfed

@dansup
Definitely, the black one!
@pixelfed

@dansup @pixelfed I want to have an adaptive icon for Android, which will be more familiar to other social media icons :)

@dansup @pixelfed

If the left one didn't have the colored ring, I would probably vote for it.

@dansup@mastodon.social you know that its a really bad idea the like vs reblog... why not a poll?

@dansup @pixelfed ooooor make them an option like other apps do!

@dansup @pixelfed black one, heck yeah

@dansup @pixelfed I like the black one

@dansup @pixelfed get rid of the white circle and make a super colorful P 🫶

@dansup @pixelfed I kinda wish it'd retain it's rainbow with the full colour background

@dansup @pixelfed neither! i find the right one too much instagram like and the left one too cluttered :P

may i suggest you to change the left one?
- bigger P
- the P has to be white on black
- so it's gonna be black around the P and i think that also the ''fake camera objective'' (idk how to call that, sorry lol) should then transition in white lines and black fillings

even tho i think it's a bit against your branding to use that as the main one still :o

mmmmhhhh...

@dansup @pixelfed I prefer the one with the black background. The colored background reminds me very much of the Instagram logo which seems quite cheap to me in itself.

@dansup @pixelfed

It would make more sense to do this as two posts, both of which people can like to vote for. Some people won't boost posts without meaningful alt texts (both images here say the exact same thing with no distinction between them), and some people may not feel comfortable boosting this to their audience at all.

The other alternative would be to do a post with the two images, and then reply to that with a poll that people could vote on.

@dansup @pixelfed Love the color one.

@dansup @pixelfed That's flawed, because every repost causes more reactions, a simple like does not.

I take the blacker/darker one.

@dansup @pixelfed

@dansup @pixelfed
I think it's important to differentiate from the competition so I'm feeling black

@dansup @pixelfed Left one every single time! 🤩🤩

@dansup @pixelfed I say use both! Let people choose in the settings! Original #Twitter & @IceCubesApp lets people select their device icons.

Maybe #Pixelfed could do the same as well.